9 Comments:

frankp said...

Couple of notes on my blog!

1:10 AM  

Anonymous said...

I thought the one you rejected Frank was better than the one you ended up going with-more colour and energy, but then again that might be just me.

1:24 PM  

frankp said...

I know what you mean, but I just don't think it was funny at all. I wanted a sketchy energetic type of illustration which I managed to achieve (albeit not as odd looking as I had intended), but when I was finished it just didn't seem funny at all.

I think the one we published here is funnier, and achieved the oddness I wanted in the earlier draft.

But as you point out, it's all a matter of taste.

I wonder does anyone else prefer the rejected version?

2:07 PM  

Bif said...

I'd imagine folks are just used to the more colourful style of cartoon.

2:43 PM  

frankp said...

True, and it's worth mentioning again that we will be doing more of the more recognisable BifSniff style, we're just experimenting a bit because we can - that way if we stumble on something worth exploring we can look at having a mix of different types of material on the site...

3:18 PM  

Anonymous said...

The rejected one looks like something from an anti drink campaign. Looks very good.. but I think the one you went with is funnier. Keep it up.

2:48 PM  

aoife said...

chortle - just to say for what it's worth, so far I have grinned at each and every of your cartoons I've seen - keep it up funnypeople

12:14 AM  

Rikki said...

I loves it :)
Don't listen to the crazies.
I love your site and ummm... keep it up.

10:27 AM  

Bif said...

Thanks Aoife, it's worth a lot really even if I can't show it for fear of damaging my carefully cultivated hardman image.

Ta too Rikki but I'm afraid if I stop listening to the crazies, then nobody will be talking to me.

8:33 PM  

Post a Comment

<< Home